Three capitals published one and the same document on Thursday, but each put the names in its own order. In Moscow it appeared as the Declaration of the Heads of State of Russia, China and the United States on Peace, in Washington as the U.S.-Russia-China Heads of State Declaration toward Peace, and in Beijing as the China-Russia-U.S. Heads of State Declaration toward Peace. Each has its own title, but the four points of the text match word for word. The short document from Shenzhen shows what the three powers are ready to say together, and the leaders left everything else to their spoken statements.
Shenzhen in numbers
- 4
points in the declaration of Russia, China and the US - 3
titles for one document, one per capital - 60-plus
local conflicts in the world, according to Xi Jinping - 19–20 November
Vladimir Putin’s visit to Tajikistan
According to the Kremlin, the White House and the Chinese Foreign Ministry
- 4
Four points for three
Russian President Vladimir Putin, Chinese President Xi Jinping and US President Donald Trump met on the sidelines of the APEC summit. In his opening remarks Xi called it the first trilateral summit in such a format in history and said it was truly a landmark. The document adopted at the end fits into four points. The three permanent members of the UN Security Council promise to reform the UN so that it can respond more effectively to global challenges. They plan to increase the production and supply of refined petroleum products and reaffirm the importance of stable energy flows. The principle of state consent and the immunities of state officials are described as paramount, and the International Criminal Court and similar bodies are told not to abuse their jurisdiction. The last point repeats the long-standing formula that a nuclear war cannot be won and promises a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and on non-proliferation.
Trump went further than the text. “We are the three biggest nuclear powers,” he said, in the translation published by the Kremlin, and proposed discussing how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons in the world. In the same breath he admitted that giving up such weapons is hard, and the declaration contains only a promise to talk about risks, without a word about cutting arsenals.
Ukraine left out
The declaration says nothing about the war between Russia and Ukraine, although it was discussed at length. In the same conversation Trump said that he and Putin had discussed the conflict for quite a long time and added that, in his view, they were moving in the right direction. At his press conference Putin spoke about compromises: the compromises had been proposed by the American side, and Russia had agreed to them unchanged, including in Anchorage. Whether Ukraine and what he called its European sponsors want to accept these compromises, Putin asked and answered himself: judging by what can be seen at the moment, no.
At the same press conference Putin closed one door. After the strikes on the Crimean bridge, he said, Russia will not negotiate either a “regime of silence” at sea or a halt to strikes on energy facilities, and will respond instead. He recalled that Ukraine had begun striking Russian tankers in the Black Sea and that Russia had responded “in a mirror fashion”.
Oil products and the Black Sea
For Kazakhstan, the closest parts of the Shenzhen text are the second point and the Black Sea part of the press conference. The main flow of Kazakh oil reaches the world market as CPC Blend through the Caspian Pipeline Consortium terminal near Novorossiysk, on the very sea where, according to Putin, tankers are being struck by both sides. The three powers’ promise to raise output of oil products coincided with Kazakhstan’s own plans: the Atyrau refinery, as we reported earlier in the day, intends to raise throughput to 6.7 million tonnes a year.
The APEC summit ended with its own declaration, and energy is near the top there too. The leaders of the group’s economies, as reported by TASS, recognised the importance of secure and uninterrupted energy supplies and agreed to develop digital technologies and artificial intelligence and to counter corruption. Ukraine, Iran and the Middle East are not mentioned in the text. The twenty-one APEC economies and the three powers in Shenzhen converged on two things: concern for energy supplies and silence about the wars of today.
Taiwan in the Chinese record
Xi also met Trump separately, and what was said about Taiwan at that meeting is known from the Chinese Foreign Ministry’s readout. According to that record, Trump said that the United States does not support “Taiwan Independence”. Xi, for his part, urged the American side to keep doing the right thing on the Taiwan question and avoid major setbacks in relations, and proposed working together to ensure that artificial intelligence always stays under human control. The two sides agreed to draw up an action plan on building a constructive relationship of strategic stability between the two countries.
The road to Dushanbe
From Shenzhen, Putin’s route leads to Central Asia. According to the Kremlin, on 19–20 November he will pay a working visit to Tajikistan at the invitation of the President of the Republic of Tajikistan Emomali Rahmon to discuss the strategic partnership and alliance of the two countries and international and regional issues. So the conversation about peace that the three began in Shenzhen moves next door to Kazakhstan, for which both oil products and the Black Sea route are matters not of diplomacy but of economics.


