Zelensky talks of US bases in Ukraine, though the Constitution bans them

A drawing: scales with the caption “Constitution”
VRK News graphic. AI-generated

Kyiv, 21 November. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has linked security guarantees for Ukraine modelled on Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty to the presence of US and European troops and military bases on Ukrainian territory.

He said so to reporters in Berlin on the evening of 19 November, after a meeting of the “coalition of the willing” and talks with US special envoys. Ukraine’s Constitution expressly prohibits foreign military bases, and it cannot be amended under martial law.

“For me, Article 5 is above all the presence of forces of the United States and European partners — troops, bases,” Zelensky said, according to the recording of the briefing quoted by the Ukrainian outlet LIGA. “Without this, I am not sure that it is Article 4, Article 5 and so on,” he added. He also spoke of bases as a wish: “We would be glad if we had American bases, as in the Middle East,” European Pravda reported. He went on to ask, “And what about American soldiers?”, admitting he did not yet have an answer. At the same time, according to the account of RBC-Ukraine, he said: “I am neither for nor against.”

Russian Telegram channels render Zelensky’s words more briefly, as if he said that “Ukraine’s security guarantees must provide for the deployment of American and European troops and military bases on Ukrainian territory”. There is no such ready-made formula in the recording of the briefing. Zelensky was reflecting on what a guarantee “like Article 5, but without NATO” is worth, and named the presence of troops and bases as something without which he is not confident in such a guarantee.

The last part of Article 17 of Ukraine’s Constitution reads: “The location of foreign military bases shall not be permitted on the territory of Ukraine.” The second part of Article 157 adds: “The Constitution of Ukraine shall not be amended in conditions of martial law or a state of emergency.” Martial law has been in force in Ukraine since 24 February 2022.

The ban concerns bases specifically, that is, permanent deployment. The Constitution does allow foreign troops in temporarily: under paragraph 23 of the first part of Article 85, the Verkhovna Rada approves decisions on admitting units of other states’ armed forces to Ukrainian territory. That is how foreign troops have come to Ukraine for exercises. The earlier clause allowing foreign military formations to stay temporarily at existing bases on lease terms was removed by the Verkhovna Rada from the Constitution’s transitional provisions in February 2019, together with the amendments on the course towards the EU and NATO. The Russian Black Sea Fleet’s presence in Crimea had rested on that clause.

Allowing foreign bases would require amending Article 17. It sits in Chapter I of the Constitution, and under Article 156 changes to that chapter, once voted by the Rada, must be approved by an all-Ukrainian referendum. Ivan Horodyskyi, director of the School of Law at the Ukrainian Catholic University, wrote as early as 2019 that permanent bases would need exactly such an amendment with a referendum. Oleksii Reznikov, then defence minister, proposed in July 2023 lifting the ban, calling it a restriction that had “lost its relevance”.

What it means: Zelensky is discussing guarantees that Ukraine’s current Constitution does not allow: foreign bases are banned, and the ban cannot be lifted before martial law ends. The temporary presence of foreign units with the Rada’s consent, however, is possible even now.

What we know now: The Kremlin has made no official response to these particular words. Russian President Vladimir Putin called the deployment of foreign troops to Ukraine unacceptable on the same day, 19 November, before Zelensky’s briefing.

Background: Article 5 of the North Atlantic Treaty obliges NATO members to regard an attack on one of them as an attack on all. Ukraine is not a NATO member, and the formula of guarantees “like Article 5, but without NATO” is being discussed in talks on ending the war involving the United States, Russia and European countries.