Sixteenth place: what the UN actually measured and what it is worth

The UN Headquarters on the East River in New York, October 2023
Archive photo. Source: Jakub Hałun / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0

Kazakhstan has risen in the UN e-government ranking from twenty-fourth place to sixteenth and entered the top rating class of the table for the first time. The Ministry of Artificial Intelligence and Digital Development announced this on the morning of 20 November, but behind the ministry’s figures lies a report worth reading in full. It shows both the strengths of Kazakhstan’s digital state and the point where it lags noticeably behind its neighbours in the table.

  • Kazakhstan in the UN ranking

    • 16
      place out of 194 countries
    • 0.9363
      EGDI in 2026
    • 0.9009
      EGDI in 2024
    • 0.6675
      world average
    • 21
      countries in the top VH class

    According to the UN E-Government Survey 2026

What the table is

The UN Department of Economic and Social Affairs has published the E-Government Survey every two years for a quarter of a century. The current, fourteenth edition was presented in New York on 19 November. For the first time it covers 194 countries: the State of Palestine was added to the 193 UN members.

The report’s main measure is the E-Government Development Index (EGDI). It is made up equally of three parts. The Online Services Index (OSI) shows what the state offers citizens online and how. The Human Capital Index (HCI) describes the education and digital literacy of the population, and the Telecommunications Infrastructure Index (TII) covers connectivity, the internet and the state’s digital foundations. Each part accounts for exactly a third of the final value.

The world as a whole has moved forward in two years: the average index value, according to the report, rose from 0.6382 to 0.6675. There are now 151 countries in the high and very high groups, against 138 in 2024. But the gap has not gone away: almost two billion people, 24.3% of the world’s population, live in countries with a below-average index.

Where we are in the table

Kazakhstan scored 0.9363, against 0.9009 two years earlier, and took sixteenth place. The report singles this out: page 11 says Kazakhstan advanced “from twenty-fourth place to sixteenth” and that Central Asia entered the leading group for the first time through Kazakhstan. Three countries entered the top VH rating class for the first time this year: Ireland, Kazakhstan and Poland.

The top class is small, 21 states. Fifteen are ahead of Kazakhstan: the Republic of Korea (0.9794), Denmark, Singapore, Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Iceland, the United Kingdom, Estonia, Finland, Australia, Spain, Norway, the United States, Bahrain and the Netherlands (0.9392). Behind it in the same class are Sweden, Germany, Ireland, New Zealand and Poland. The distance between fifteenth and sixteenth place is less than three thousandths of a point, while fifth place is already three and a half hundredths away.

Kazakhstan has overtaken countries that stood higher in 2024. Germany, according to the tables of the previous report, was twelfth with an index of 0.9382 and has now slipped to eighteenth with 0.9278. Sweden slid from fourteenth to seventeenth, New Zealand from sixteenth to twentieth. Ireland raised its index from 0.9138 to 0.9196, but its place changed little, from twentieth to nineteenth: Kazakhstan simply grew faster. Japan, according to the report, dropped out of the top class altogether.

What drove it

The most interesting part begins when the three components are taken apart. For online services Kazakhstan scored 0.9444, almost the same as two years ago (0.9390). This was already a strength: the public services portal and app give the tenth-highest value among the twenty-one countries of the top class, above Finland, the United States and Germany. But there was no leap in services as such over the two years.

The leap came from the other two parts. Telecommunications infrastructure rose from 0.9235 to 0.9720, exactly the level of Estonia, usually regarded as a model digital state. Human capital gained the most: from 0.8403 to 0.8924.

And yet human capital remains the weak spot. Among the twenty-one countries of the top class, only Bahrain is lower on this measure than Kazakhstan. Finland has 0.9854, Germany 0.9652, and Australia the maximum of one. In other words, the state has learned to offer services online and has built out connectivity, but the education and skills of the population, as the UN measures them, lag furthest behind the leaders.

There is also a caveat without which talk of growth would be dishonest. In 2026 the UN updated the internal structure of the index: the questionnaire for assessing portals grew from 183 to 211 indicators, a new “e-government infrastructure” block was added to the infrastructure index, and “e-government literacy” to human capital. Both new blocks are built from assessments of government portals rather than from data on connectivity or schools. The UN itself calls this an evolution of measurement rather than a methodological break and says the structure of the index has not changed. But comparing the 2024 and 2026 sub-indices one-to-one calls for caution: part of the gain may have come from the new yardstick.

What it is worth

The answer comes from the report itself, and it is more sober than any press release. The UN index is primarily a supply-side measure: how ready the state is to deliver services digitally. The report’s summary states plainly that the index does not, by itself, measure how many people actually use the services or how satisfied they are. The technical notes add that online services are assessed through the national portal and ministry websites, without counting users, satisfaction or outcomes, and that a drop of a couple of places with close values does not necessarily mean deterioration.

The assessment is done by people: the report was prepared by 287 volunteer researchers from 127 countries, with each country reviewed independently by two of them in its official languages. That is why the phrase of Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Artificial Intelligence and Digital Development Zhaslan Madiyev, “the UN does not assess websites, but how the state works as a whole”, as quoted by the ministry, is at odds with the methodology: a third of the index, online services, is built precisely on the study of portals. The ranking does not see the state as a whole — it sees its shop window, its connectivity and the education of its citizens.

None of this devalues sixteenth place. It means that in readiness for digital government Kazakhstan stands alongside the Netherlands and Sweden, ahead of Germany and Japan, and that Central Asia has entered the leading group for the first time. The report also notes the rise of neighbours: Kyrgyzstan moved into the very high group, and Turkmenistan climbed a group higher.

The place is best used as a map rather than a medal. The map shows that further growth can come not only from yet another app: in online services Kazakhstan is already close to the leaders. The lag is in people: in education, skills and the ability to use what the state has built. The survey comes out every two years, and the next one will show whether the gap is narrowing in exactly this column.